ShopDreamUp AI ArtDreamUp
Deviation Actions
Suggested Deviants
Suggested Collections
You Might Like…
Description
Surprise Motherfucka!
After a big debate within myself, I have decided to make an Edgic for TDAS. I want to challenge myself and could help me get back into the Edgic groove and hopefully compete in the SFC12 Edgic Comparisons and settle the score if me or
will be the 3-peat Edgic Champ. But as for TDAS, the winner is going to be much complicated since it's more the story rather than the Edgic overall......let's just get this started.
After a big debate within myself, I have decided to make an Edgic for TDAS. I want to challenge myself and could help me get back into the Edgic groove and hopefully compete in the SFC12 Edgic Comparisons and settle the score if me or
will be the 3-peat Edgic Champ. But as for TDAS, the winner is going to be much complicated since it's more the story rather than the Edgic overall......let's just get this started.
O_o Da fuck? The person I least thought would win ended up winning. Then again the story made sense after seeing the end of his multi-personalities and might have some psychological story with it. But it "might have" hurt him overall. But like I said, it depends since I didn't watch/remember Revenge of the Island. Overall the winner wasn't THAT bad.
Result: Edgic Failure! 
I really can't be mad. Not a good idea to start an Edgic with one of the most unpredictable TD Winners (with the exception to TDWT)
I really can't be mad. Not a good idea to start an Edgic with one of the most unpredictable TD Winners (with the exception to TDWT)1. 
Mike/Mal - As I said I never watched much of RotI so I can't say based on his last appearance. At first he seemed okay, but Mal being such a fascinating villain since he was introduced. It was also interesting that Duncan is the only one who recognize him. But I felt Mal could have done more, he had the potential and become in the same villain status as Heather and Alejandro. Sometimes he did that, but other times, he didn't. And I was a bit disappointed with that. But on story wise was interesting through Mike and not Mal. What I mean is him in a struggle with his identity which especially showed in the 2nd to last episode where his personalities are bashing Mike for. And the ending was kind of touching and his personalities are gone, but he still has some of their traits. Interesting character, interesting story, but lots of wasted potential.
Mike/Mal - As I said I never watched much of RotI so I can't say based on his last appearance. At first he seemed okay, but Mal being such a fascinating villain since he was introduced. It was also interesting that Duncan is the only one who recognize him. But I felt Mal could have done more, he had the potential and become in the same villain status as Heather and Alejandro. Sometimes he did that, but other times, he didn't. And I was a bit disappointed with that. But on story wise was interesting through Mike and not Mal. What I mean is him in a struggle with his identity which especially showed in the 2nd to last episode where his personalities are bashing Mike for. And the ending was kind of touching and his personalities are gone, but he still has some of their traits. Interesting character, interesting story, but lots of wasted potential.2. 
Zoey - Okay, I got over my Zoey is a Goddess schtick. But now realizing her overall, she was just there. Sure she had her boring moments, but she didn't bother me too much. She was nice and sane (which we needed since everyone else was just batshit insane), but also had some bit of fun along the road. The only thing that I felt she could have improved on her was more of her personality and Commander Zoey. ;_; where was that Zoey? Commando Zoey vs Mal would have been epic, but sadly it's as if it wasn't meant to be.
Lodge of Shame
3.
Scott- OMG! This is one of the funniest characters in TDAS, instead of being the Russell Hantz wannabee, he was an absolute hilarious god. He wasn't being a mastermind, but he was all entertainment. Being the punching bag, can't take him everything seriously, his relationship with Courtney was so funny. ("I love a girl who bosses me around"), and I hate to say it, him getting the torture and pain was hilarious. I also liked some interesting facts about him in the outside game. Overall he was a major improvement from his RotI self. <3 <3 <3
Zoey - Okay, I got over my Zoey is a Goddess schtick. But now realizing her overall, she was just there. Sure she had her boring moments, but she didn't bother me too much. She was nice and sane (which we needed since everyone else was just batshit insane), but also had some bit of fun along the road. The only thing that I felt she could have improved on her was more of her personality and Commander Zoey. ;_; where was that Zoey? Commando Zoey vs Mal would have been epic, but sadly it's as if it wasn't meant to be.Lodge of Shame
3.
Scott- OMG! This is one of the funniest characters in TDAS, instead of being the Russell Hantz wannabee, he was an absolute hilarious god. He wasn't being a mastermind, but he was all entertainment. Being the punching bag, can't take him everything seriously, his relationship with Courtney was so funny. ("I love a girl who bosses me around"), and I hate to say it, him getting the torture and pain was hilarious. I also liked some interesting facts about him in the outside game. Overall he was a major improvement from his RotI self. <3 <3 <34. Gwen- At the first half of the season she was amazing. The redemption ark from being shown as a villain to becoming a hero she was back in Total Drama Island. Her relationship with Courtney was one of the best moments of the season. Glad things resolved between her, but I felt it might have been a bit too early for that to happen, plus I would have loved her more if she got eliminated at the F5 instead of Courtney so she can pass the torch for a hero. I knew she wasn't going to win, but after her resolve with Courtney, she died down and her episode of betraying Courtney was kind of mean (even if Courtney was also to blame with her chart)
Gwen- At the first half of the season she was amazing. The redemption ark from being shown as a villain to becoming a hero she was back in Total Drama Island. Her relationship with Courtney was one of the best moments of the season. Glad things resolved between her, but I felt it might have been a bit too early for that to happen, plus I would have loved her more if she got eliminated at the F5 instead of Courtney so she can pass the torch for a hero. I knew she wasn't going to win, but after her resolve with Courtney, she died down and her episode of betraying Courtney was kind of mean (even if Courtney was also to blame with her chart)5. Courtney- GODDESS! This is hands down Courtney's best season in a character way. She had all the fierceness, but also showed a different side we haven't seen since Total Drama Island. Her arc with Gwen was the highlight of the first half of the season. Sure she was a bitch and sure she was annoying, but I really appreciate what she brought to this game. Her boot was pretty tragic. If only Mike hadn't found Courtney's chart. ;( You shall be missed my lady.
Courtney- GODDESS! This is hands down Courtney's best season in a character way. She had all the fierceness, but also showed a different side we haven't seen since Total Drama Island. Her arc with Gwen was the highlight of the first half of the season. Sure she was a bitch and sure she was annoying, but I really appreciate what she brought to this game. Her boot was pretty tragic. If only Mike hadn't found Courtney's chart. ;( You shall be missed my lady.6. Alejandro- In the early episodes with Heather, he was just boring and not that interesting. But his last 2 episodes were amazing. His rivalry with Mal in those episodes were fantastic and epic. A villain facing against another villain. Perfect story and perfect ending especially since the season is coming to a close.
Alejandro- In the early episodes with Heather, he was just boring and not that interesting. But his last 2 episodes were amazing. His rivalry with Mal in those episodes were fantastic and epic. A villain facing against another villain. Perfect story and perfect ending especially since the season is coming to a close.7. 
Cameron- Most of the time you were just irrelevant and meh, but your last 2 episodes were hilarious. It's funny when he's the only person to quit, gets voted out, and medically evacuated in one season Other than those moments, you were just meh.
8.Duncan- Wow.....what can I say, this was Duncan's best performance. He was funny, entertaining, and had a great story arc. The fall of Gwen x Duncan, his story of Mal, and his inner conflicts between a hero and a villain. Plus he left at the right time with a great ending. He turns into a villain again, which backfires and sends him to prison. <3
Cameron- Most of the time you were just irrelevant and meh, but your last 2 episodes were hilarious. It's funny when he's the only person to quit, gets voted out, and medically evacuated in one season Other than those moments, you were just meh.8.
Duncan- Wow.....what can I say, this was Duncan's best performance. He was funny, entertaining, and had a great story arc. The fall of Gwen x Duncan, his story of Mal, and his inner conflicts between a hero and a villain. Plus he left at the right time with a great ending. He turns into a villain again, which backfires and sends him to prison. <39. Sierra- At first I liked her, but she was starting to get very repetitive and wasn't that entertaining anymore. Liked you in TDWT, here not so much.
10.Heather- Epic blindside! First 4 Episodes were meh, but her last 2 episodes were amazing. So many good moments from her. Sadly her cockiness fucked her over big time.
11.Sam- One word. Letdown. I thought there was going to be something unique about Sam since he was here in an All-Star Season. Kind of boring and his antics of being a punching bag kind of gotten tiring.
12.Jo- Meh. She was okay for her 3 episodes. I did appreciate causing some drama, but it wasn't enough for me to like like her.
13.Lightning- I think he left at the right place in the right time before he got irritating. I never saw RoTI, so my impression of him was LOL. I love how his cockiness and his self-absorbant that makes Gaston look like a wimp cause his elimination. If he went further his Sha-clique would have gotten annoying.
14.Lindsay- OMG! Robbed! Sad for her to leave. You will not be forgotten 
I'll most likely make a separate ranking of Total Drama All-Stars sometime this week. Keep an eye out folks.
Sierra- At first I liked her, but she was starting to get very repetitive and wasn't that entertaining anymore. Liked you in TDWT, here not so much.10.
Heather- Epic blindside! First 4 Episodes were meh, but her last 2 episodes were amazing. So many good moments from her. Sadly her cockiness fucked her over big time.11.
Sam- One word. Letdown. I thought there was going to be something unique about Sam since he was here in an All-Star Season. Kind of boring and his antics of being a punching bag kind of gotten tiring.12.
Jo- Meh. She was okay for her 3 episodes. I did appreciate causing some drama, but it wasn't enough for me to like like her.13.
Lightning- I think he left at the right place in the right time before he got irritating. I never saw RoTI, so my impression of him was LOL. I love how his cockiness and his self-absorbant that makes Gaston look like a wimp cause his elimination. If he went further his Sha-clique would have gotten annoying.14.
Lindsay- OMG! Robbed! Sad for her to leave. You will not be forgotten I'll most likely make a separate ranking of Total Drama All-Stars sometime this week. Keep an eye out folks.
Image size
793x402px 38.94 KB
© 2013 - 2024 shadow0knight
Comments36
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Log In
Not really an Edgic Failure. Since Unless they changed the formula, the viewers decided who won, so it'll be an Edgic victory if you live in a country where Zoey ends up winning